Kevin Costner, who celebrated his 70th birthday on January 18, 2025, has had a prolific career in Hollywood, delivering numerous memorable performances. While films like “Dances with Wolves,” “JFK,” and “The Bodyguard” are widely acclaimed, several of his works remain underappreciated. Here, we explore seven of Kevin Costner’s most underrated films that showcase his versatility and talent.

1. Wyatt Earp (1994)

In “Wyatt Earp,” Costner takes on the titular role of the legendary lawman, chronicling his life from a young man to his days enforcing law and order in the Wild West. The film provides a comprehensive look at Earp’s life, exploring his personal and professional challenges. While it didn’t achieve the same acclaim as other Westerns of its time, Costner’s dedication to the role offers a deep and thoughtful portrayal of a complex historical figure.

2. Revenge (1990)

Directed by Tony Scott, “Revenge” is a gripping thriller where Costner plays Michael “Jay” Cochran, a former Navy pilot who becomes entangled in a dangerous affair with the wife of a powerful crime boss, portrayed by Anthony Quinn. The film masterfully blends romance and suspense, showcasing Costner’s ability to navigate complex emotional landscapes. Despite being overshadowed by other releases at the time, “Revenge” stands as a testament to Costner’s range as an actor.

3. The Highwaymen (2019)

In this Netflix original, Costner teams up with Woody Harrelson to play Frank Hamer and Maney Gault, two former Texas Rangers tasked with capturing the notorious criminals Bonnie and Clyde. The film offers a fresh perspective on the infamous duo’s pursuit, focusing on the lawmen’s determination and moral dilemmas. Costner’s portrayal of Hamer is both nuanced and commanding, bringing depth to a historical figure often relegated to the sidelines.

4. Mr. Brooks (2007)

“Mr. Brooks” presents Costner in a darker role as Earl Brooks, a successful businessman leading a double life as a serial killer. The film delves into his internal struggle between his murderous impulses and his desire to maintain a normal family life. Costner’s chilling performance is complemented by William Hurt, who plays his sinister alter ego, and Demi Moore as the detective on his trail. This psychological thriller is a departure from Costner’s typical roles, showcasing his versatility.

5. McFarland, USA (2015)

In “McFarland, USA,” Costner portrays Jim White, a down-on-his-luck sports coach who relocates to a small town in California’s Central Valley. Discovering the exceptional running abilities of his students, primarily from Latino backgrounds, he forms a cross-country team that overcomes social and economic challenges to achieve remarkable success. This heartwarming film highlights themes of perseverance and cultural integration, with Costner delivering a sincere and compelling performance.
image source: imdb.com

Final thoughts

These films highlight Kevin Costner’s ability to embody diverse characters across various genres, from sports dramas and thrillers to Westerns and comedies. While they may not have garnered the same attention as his blockbuster hits, they offer compelling narratives and showcase the depth of his acting prowess. As Costner enters his seventh decade, revisiting these underrated gems provides a comprehensive appreciation of his contributions to cinema.